How to Train your dog: learning and teaching styles

How to Train your Dog: Which learning/ teaching style do you use?

Understanding animal training can be confusing. Dr Jo explains training/teaching and learning styles in a simple, easy to understand manner. Scroll down for video help in training your dog. And encourages owners to use positive reinforcement…

Do you train your pet? The answer is yes you do, whether you are aware of it or not. Pets are always learning. They learn what works for them and repeat this behaviour. If you wish your pet to behave in a different way, then you need to teach them.

I often find that there is confusion among pet owners, especially dog owners, about how to train their pets. Many have heard of positive, motivational training and want to remain as positive as possible but sometimes punishment creeps in. Then there’s negative reinforcement. Just what is this? The world of animal learning and teaching styles can be confusing. And all you want is a better behaved pet!

Teaching opportunities

So let’s look at these four learning and teaching styles…

Positive reinforcement

There is no secret that I am a big fan of positive reinforcement. Ideally this is the way we train pets. Positive reinforcement means rewarding behaviours that we desire. Rewards can be many types – treats, praise, pats, toys and more. Go with what motivates your pet. Dogs can be easy to train using positive reinforcement.

There is some evidence that food may be the most effective reinforcer of dog’s behaviour, at least in the early stages of training. When you have established the behaviour you want, it can be useful to introduce an intermittent reinforcement schedule. In other words, don’t reward behaviour every single time with a treat. Your dog will work even more for you to get that desired reward.

If you ever feel frustrated by using this technique and think you are spoiling your dog by offering too many rewards, consider how you would teach a cat. Would punishment work? Not likely. Positive reinforcement is the way to go with most animals. Think rewards!

Negative reinforcement

While negative reinforcement can confuse many pet owners, it is really quite simple. The pet is rewarded by removing a stimulus. So imagine using a head halter. When the dog pulls on the halter, they feel discomfort to their muzzle area. When they stop pulling, the discomfort ceases. This is negative reinforcement. The reinforcement comes from removal of the stimulus.

Negative reinforcement can be useful but will be even more powerful when applied with positive reinforcement. So, for instance, when your dog stops pulling on the lead due to the use of a head halter, you can then issue a command to ‘Walk’ and reward (positively reinforce) the desired non-pulling behaviour. This will ensure long-term learning.

A negative reinforcer should never cause pain to the animal. It is intended to be a management tool. When it is used incorrectly it becomes positive punishment.

Positive punishment

In positive punishment a punishment is applied to an animal when an undesirable behaviour is performed. Positive does not equal favourable. Positive equals the application of a behaviour on to the animal (as opposed to a negative which is taking a behaviour away). Examples of positive punishment include the jerk of a check chain (although these can also be a negative reinforcer), shouting at your dog, rubbing their nose in waste products (yes, some people still do this!!), holding them down to the floor, pinching ears or hurting them in any physical manner.

Some trainers still claim that this is the only or the best method to use with certain animals. There is no doubt that positive punishment does tend to stop a behaviour but perhaps only as an interruption, not always a permanent solution. Shouting at your barking dog shuts them up for a minute. It is then desirable to come in with your positive reinforcer for quiet behaviour. Reward your dog for being quiet (positive reinforcement).

Owners often get the timing wrong with punishment. No use punishing your dog after the event had occurred, as they cannot associate their behaviour with your punishment. Punishment is unlikely to build a better bond between dog and handler. It may not even stop the unwanted behaviour, simply ensure that the animal performs the same behaviour but only in the absense of the punisher!

The use of positive punishment has been shown to be eventually met with aggressive responses from dogs. Even yelling at a dog may eventually cause them to respond in an aggressive manner to their handlers or owners. Use of punishment and negative reinforcement has been shown to increase the chances of aggressive behaviour towards people both within and outside of the home. The use of punishment has also been shown to result in dogs that are less playful and who are less likely to interact with strangers, possibly because they are more watchful and wary of the response they may receive.

Don’t like the idea of punishment for your dog? Well, it seems you are in the minority! Over 70% of owners were found to use some form of punishment on their dogs! Stop yelling and get more creative in your use of positive reinforcers.

Negative punishment

Negative punishment may seem like a hard definition to work your head around but all it means is taking something good or desirable away to reduce the occurrence of a particular behaviour. So if your dog is jumping up on your guests and you put your dog in another room, as a time out, this is negative punishment.

People often mistakenly believe that negative punishment will help their dog learn. Your dog is not sitting in isolation lamenting his ‘bad’ behaviour. Your dog will return to the room, to the same stimulus and perform the same undesirable behaviour (if not this time, then the next) unless your have taught them how you would like them to behave. Be proactive and teach your dog.

Training your pets: What’s your teaching style?

Try, wherever possible, to be a positive, motivational teacher. Yes, we can all use punishing techniques at times, due to frustration, ignorance or feeling that being positive does not work. You may actually have to look at your teaching style and technique and reward yourself for remaining positive. Build a better bond with your pet by training them in a positive manner.

Video help with training your dog

Training dogs can seem like hard work. Now you can get some video help and tips from Dr Jo Righetti on simple dog training.

Dogs with manners are highly valued in our community. Imagine if your dog did NOT pull on the lead, sniff people’s crotches or came back to you when you called them – every time. A little training goes a long way. even just a minute a day can make a huge difference to your dog’s behaviour.

Why not try some basic commands with your dog. Some tips are given in the videos here…

1. Teaching basic dog commands

2. Teaching your dog tricks

Remember to use whatever motivates your dog. If your dog loves your praise, use it lots. If they love food, save their favourite treat for when you are teaching them a new command. Be patient! food, save their favourite treat for when you are teaching them a new command. Be patient!

Of course, this video help is for you the dog owner. We hope these tips have helped you understand how to train your dog. Remember though that your dog can’t watch and learn! A well-mannered dog is all about the time and patience that the owners puts in to the relationship. Have patience but give some simple dog training a go!

Further info on pet training

Training styles and dog-owner interactions
Use of reinforcers in dog training
Punishment and behaviour problems in dogs
Punishment and negative reinforcement increase dog aggression
Aggression met with aggression
Punishment in horses

More behaviour information

• Predicting the behaviour of rescue dogs. New Research to Improve Adoptability
  Predicting the behaviour of rescue dogs : It’s difficult to compare a shelter to a sofa! Are you thinking about adopting a rescue dog from a shelter?
• Does The Anxiety Wrap work?
  Does the Anxiety Wrap Work? Does your dog suffer from anxieties, fears or phobias? Stress is common in our pet dogs and most owners want to find
• Top 10 Problem Pets – and Problem Pet Behaviour
  Are you frustrated, angry or puzzled y your pet’s behaviour? Here’s your guide to the top 10 problem pets and problem cat behaviour and dog behaviour…
• Road tripping with a dog with car anxiety
  If your dog is anxious while you travel, these tips, from Sarah Archer at Your Best Digs, may help… Road tripping with a dog with car anxiety
• A Day In The Life of A Pet Care Centre
  Do you ever wish that your dog was better behaved or perhaps just had more activities to occupy them? A pet care centre could be the answer
• The Lazy Guide to Dog Training
  The Lazy Guide to Dog training by animal behaviourist (and lazy dog trainer!) Dr Jo Righetti… This blog post is part of the 2018 #Train4Rewards Blog Party
• Did You Know That Desexing your male dog could result in unwanted behaviour?
  Desexing your male dog could result in unwanted behaviour! Dog owners: Do you have a male dog? Is your dog desexed (neutered) ? At what age was
• How to Stop Your Dog from Jumping and Climbing the Fence
  How to Stop Your Dog from Jumping and Climbing the Fence Has your dog ever escaped from your backyard? Some dogs are pure escape artists and others
• Relaxing your pets with music, audiobooks and movies
  Relaxing your pets with music, audiobooks and movies Is it possible to relax stressed pets by playing them music, audiobooks or watching movies? Dr Jo explores recent